I am also not a moderator...lol.   

Different moderators may look at the queue at different times adn judge differently.  Especially in the "pure art" wallpaper gallery.  Sometimes it's luck of the draw.  On average . . it works out.

I would sumise... that one passed and one didnt....further more to add to this... the one that didn't, didnt because it didn't, the one that did, did.

Well now that weve cleared this up. Im off to run for a gov office 

You got my vote, you have confused me more so than any politician to date!   

You are just pissed because you need more karma!!   

Both have the same tonal value (as I see it) but in my mind top grey has the edge over green cause’ it has a ‘centre’ making it a tad more interesting!

If you want people to check out your stuff in your personal gallery, put a link on every submission to your WC page. That way, you have a 50/50 chance that more of your stuff will get seen. And in this case, whichever wall made it to the gallery, edit the description and put a link to the other one...then resubmit. Don't change anything but the description...don't reload the graphics, it won't go back through moderation.   

I'll never figure out why some make it into the main gallery while others get pp'ed.

I read once that generaly if they get rated by the mods at 2 1/2 stars, they make it into the main gallery, but I've seen walls rated lower and still go on the main gallery. Dunno.....guess maybe it's like Zubaz said "luck of the draw".

You can either try to figure it out or do like me; shrug and stop uploading wallpapers to wincustomize   

Id LUV to have my 2 cents on the subject...but ive promised to gag and straightjacket myself when i feel the need to have my say........  

Feel free to PM or email me your point of view, I would be interested.

---

BTW, The top one is not mine.

Good idea. I won't let this sort of thing keep me from trying. I will still upload them, so what if they go to PPO. I will get better in time and that will happen less. I am trying to take the advice of the great ZubaZ and branch out a little. So far, no luck with walls, WBs, RCs, or docks.   

Actually, I find the grey center distracting. It looks like it was just kind of thrown in and doesn't compliment the wallpaper at all. The green one is very usable and simplistic in a pleasant way. IMHO.. which is why I'm not a mod. lol.


I'm confused. The top one says the author is HAPTORK in the main gallery?

The green is Jims, the grey is Haptorks, the grey must be in the main gallery and Jim is wondering why his didn't make it since it's, in his opinion, about the same quality. That's as near as I can figure anyway. Give him a personal page elite award.

You sound just like Gov. Arnold HG!

      

Correct, and Jim just had 2 more wall sets added to his PPO. I have a PP Award already, liked the joke. And I will be good and not try to cause a stink. Wouldn't do any good anyway. But I must say that IMO, all 4 of my recent wall sets are of higher quality than alot of walls that made it to the gallery. It reminds me of the inCognito wall by Buzz that was, IMO, a very high quality wall that didn't make it. I know I am in good company, but it seems as though the walls get passed or failed purely on personal preference, rather than quality. I am , and always have been, a lover of guitar. I don't like Chet Atkins' music, but he is very good at what he does, so I rate him high. I would not give him a low rate, just because I don't like his style, because, for his style, he is a master. Just a thought.